My thoughts on The Lighthouse *spoilers*
I know I am later than most to this party, but it took ages to come out where I live, and now, I can finally say I have seen it. However, I am still conflicted as if it's amazing psychological horror or just an artsy horror flick.
Let me just state the obvious. Dafoe and Pattinson are an amazing duo, and they compliment each of their roles flawlessly. I love that Pattinson's growth throughout the film much like the entire atmosphere of the whole film, beginning eerily and moody to complete madness and chaos by the end of it all.
Then there's Dafoe. His was my favourite performance of last year by far. Everything he does is perfect. His prayers before dinner. His heckling towards Winslow. His amazing dialect. His fucking farts. All, perfect. The Sea Curse scene is probably my fav scene in the film, that and the climax with the light. The way that Dafoe doesn't blink, the shadow surrounding his face and his eyes hypnotized as much as they terrified me. Brilliant.
I think you can tell what stood out the most for me was the acting. But some shots that Eggers compose are just terrifyingly amazing. When Dafoe is being buried after being treated like a dog, and we see his face covered in dirt in the ground, stuck with me. Also there is a shot of the lighthouse being completely desolate, I don't remember exactly when, but it being surrounded by darkness of the sea and the sky just encapsulates the feeling of complete loneliness.
Now the ending, which I think has stirred most of the cerebral soup boiling after watching this. I got chills watching it, which almost never happens to me with a horror flick. The only time it happened before was when I watched Hereditary for the first time, which was the most visceral experience I have had watching a movie.
Anyway, I think the ending shows the whole point of the movie, since it tackles madness and insanity. I think Pattinson represents people trying to search for something or answers, but maybe we should leave those things alone. Pattinson is maybe the stubborn beast within all of us who refuses to give up his search for the light. Maybe the film is telling us the light is sometimes not what it seems, and will destroy you if you are not careful or unwise enough to think you deserve it.
These are just my two cents, and I would love to hear what you think. Do you agree? Disagree? I know there are many more things to discuss with this movie, such as symbolism and the way its shot etc. But these were the things that stuck out the most for me in this roller coaster.
https://redd.it/hhc3e8@r_movieclub