TAHIYYAAT WAS NOT FROM CONVERSATION WITH ALLAH ﷻ ON MI’RAAJ NIGHT
QUESTION: Please advice if the following is authentic: "Attahiyat recited during salah is actually a part of the conversation between ALLAH ﷻ and PROPHET ﷺ when he met HIM while on Miraj."
ANSWER: What you mentioned is NOT TRUE at all.
This is a COMMON saying of many PREACHERS and people who are NOT KNOWLEDGEABLE of the science of Hadeeth.
They say that the wording of TASHAHUD originated from a CONVERSATION between ALLAH ﷻ and His PROPHET ﷺ on the night of Mi’raaj (Ascension to the heavens), namely that the PROPHET ﷺ said: “All compliments, prayers, and pure words and deeds, are due to Allaah.” Allaah said: “Peace be upon you O Prophet, and the Mercy of Allaah and His Blessings be upon you.”
Then, the Prophet said: “Peace be upon us and on the righteous slaves of Allaah.” Then, the angels said: “I bear witness that there is no god but Allaah and I bear witness that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allaah.”
All this is FABRICATED and it has NI FOUNDATION in the books of Sunnah.
The Fataawa of the Permanent Committee said: “As regards the Prophet receiving the Tashahhud while prostrating himself (before Allaah) near the Lote Tree in the Highest Heaven on the night of Mi’raaj, we do not know of any foundation for that or for the prostration at that place on the night of Al-Mi’raaj.” [ISLAMWEB FATWA NO : 231700]
With regard to the above,
Shaykh ‘Abd al-‘Azeez ibn Baz, Shaykh ‘Abd al-Razzaq ‘Afeefi, Shaykh ‘Abd-Allah ibn Ghadyan, Shaykh ‘Abd-Allah ibn Qa‘ood said this:
We do NOT know of any BASIS for saying that he prostrated in that place on the night of the Mi‘raj. End quote. [FATAWA AL-LAJNAH AL-DAA’IMAH, 7/6,7]
Thus it becomes clear that it is NOT PERMISSIBLE to propagate these letters and essays that are not proven, or which contain innovations (bid‘ah) in beliefs or actions; rather no one should propagate them until after checking whether they are proven and sound.
RASULULLAH ﷺ SAID: “It is sufficient LYING for a man to speak of EVERYTHING that he HEARS.” [MUSLIM, 5.]
https://t.me/darulirshad